11 projects have been recognized as a part of the 2024 New York State Historic Preservation Awards. Projects highlighted at this year’s awards include an ambitious neighborhood rehabilitation effort in Newburgh, the restoration of an iconic candy shop in Buffalo, and the scholarship and preservation of Puerto Rican casitas in New York City.
Created in 1980, the New York State Historic Preservation Awards are presented by the Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation to honor excellence in the protection and revitalization of historic and cultural resources.
A new award category this year is the Joan K. Davidson Award. As Commissioner of New York State Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation from 1993 to 1995, Chair of the New York State Council on the Arts from 1974 to 1977, and President of the J. M. Kaplan Fund from 1977 to 1993, Joan K. Davidson (1927-2023) was a visionary leader who was dedicated to the betterment of natural and built environments from cities to rural towns and villages throughout New York State. She believed that the most successful historic preservation projects begin at the grassroots level when dedicated individuals work together to ensure the future of irreplaceable community assets and tangible links to our shared past.
This year’s 2024 New York State Historic Preservation Awards recipients are:
6967 Fillmore Avenue, Hamlet of Silver Lake, Wyoming County
- Excellence in Historic Preservation Stewardship
The house at 6967 Fillmore Avenue is recognized for Excellence in Historic Preservation Stewardship. The 1878 cottage, originally designed as seasonal lodging for a Methodist campground in the hamlet of Silver Lake, has been carefully rehabilitated by owner Bradley Huber utilizing the federal and state historic rehabilitation tax credit program. The project is a point of pride for the neighborhood and has been featured for its preservation work in national media outlets.
Bent’s Opera House, Village of Medina, Orleans County
- Joan K. Davidson Award
The Bent’s Opera House is the inaugural recipient of the Joan K. Davidson Award. The Civil War-era opera house is one of the oldest surviving opera houses in the country. Listed as one of the Preservation League of New York State’s “Seven to Save” in 2012 due to its threatened condition, the previously vacant building has been restored utilizing the state and federal historic rehabilitation tax credit program and now features a restaurant, boutique hotel, and special event space.
East End II, City of Newburgh, Orange County
- Excellence in Nonprofit Achievement
East End II is recognized for Excellence in Nonprofit Achievement. East End II was an over $30 million scattered-site, multi-year initiative by the nonprofit organization RUPCO, which utilized state and federal historic rehabilitation tax credits, affordable housing credits, and LEED certification to rehabilitate and construct over 60 mixed-income homes in Newburgh. In addition to development of housing, a former Methodist church was adaptively reused to create commercial, social, and educational space within the neighborhood.
Grave Stone Matters, Village of Hoosick Falls, Rensselaer County
- Outstanding Contributions to Historic Preservation
Grave Stone Matters is recognized for Outstanding Contributions to Historic Preservation. Owner and stone conservator Joseph Ferrannini has spent over sixteen years working to preserve thousands of gravestones and monuments in New York State and throughout the country through his hands-on repair work and special training workshops. He is motivated by the most challenging projects and his passion for this work is building a new generation of hands-on preservationists.
Hotel Chelsea, New York City, New York
- Excellence in Historic Building Preservation, Rehabilitation, or Restoration
The Hotel Chelsea is recognized for Excellence in Historic Building Preservation, Rehabilitation, or Restoration. Brimming with New York City history and connected to generations of prominent artists, novelists, and musicians, the 1884 Victorian Gothic building has been rehabilitated through significant investment, which included use of federal historic rehabilitation tax credits. Original features have been carefully restored and the hotel now includes boutique suites, a re-opened restaurant, special event spaces, and rent-controlled apartments for long-time residents.
James H. Case III and Laura Rockefeller Case House, Hamlet of Van Hornesville, Herkimer County
- Excellence in Historic Preservation Stewardship
The James H. Case III and Laura Rockefeller Case House is recognized for Excellence in Historic Preservation Stewardship. The house, constructed 1962-1964, received acclaim for its Mid-Century Modern architectural design by both House Beautiful magazine and Architectural Record. The house is notable for its prominent rooflines, geometric shapes, vertical redwood siding, and open floor plan. Current owners Max Bleiler and Doreen DeNicola utilized the state historic homeownership tax credit program to stabilize the structure – which suffered from decades of neglect – and preserved its prominent and character-defining architectural features.
Lustron House Westchester Deluxe Model M02 #01310, Town of Eden, Erie County
- Excellence in Historic Preservation Stewardship
The Lustron House Westchester Deluxe Model M02 #01310 is recognized for Excellence in Historic Preservation Stewardship. Originally erected in 1949 on a lot in Westfield, Chautauqua County, by 2015 the house was threatened by demolition or drastic alterations. Joyce Scheetz purchased the house and over the next several years- with a copy of an original Lustron Erection Manual as her guide- she carefully dismantled the house to move it and rebuild it on a new foundation in Eden. She shared her process through her blog “Lustron or Bust” and in 2023 the house was added to the State and National Registers of Historic Places.
New York City School Construction Authority, All New York City Boroughs
- Excellence in Government Achievement
The New York City School Construction Authority is recognized for Excellence in Government Achievement. The School Construction Authority oversees the buildng stock of the largest school district in the nation, with over 1,500 buildings serving 1.1 million students throughout the five boroughs of New York City. The Authority has shown energy, optimism, and commitment to its historic resources through proactive planning, sensitive rehabilitation projects, and creative solutions to modernize facilities to meet the growing needs of students and educators.
Parkside Candy, City of Buffalo, Erie County
- Excellence in Historic Building Preservation, Rehabilitation, or Restoration
Parkside Candy is recognized for Excellence in Historic Building Preservation, Rehabilitation, or Restoration. Originally built in 1927, this National Register-listed historic candy shop has been a neighborhood staple for generations. The project utilized state and federal historic rehabilitation tax credits to restore many of its 1920s decorative features, as well as its still-active factory, garage, and residential spaces.
Puerto Rican Casitas of New York City Multiple Property Nomination and Casita Rincón Criollo National Register Nomination, New York City, New York County and Bronx County
- Excellence in Historic Preservation Documentation
The Puerto Rican Casitas of New York City Multiple Property Nomination and Casita Rincón Criollo National Register Nomination are recognized for Excellence in Historic Preservation Documentation. This multiple property nomination shows exemplary depth and scholarship for a rare and fragile property type associated with Puerto Rican immigrant culture in New York City between the 1970s and late 1990s. The project was supported by an Underrepresented Communities Grant from the National Park Service and prepared by City Lore, a nonprofit cultural heritage organization serving New York City.
Victory Lofts / Endicott Johnson Victory Shoe Factory, Johnson City, Broome County
- Excellence in Historic Building Preservation, Rehabilitation, or Restoration
The Victory Lofts/ Endicott Johnson Victory Shoe Factory is recognized for Excellence in Historic Building Preservation, Rehabilitation, or Restoration. Built between 1918 and 1921, the factory was one of the world’s largest manufacturers of shoes and, at its height, employed 2,000 workers who produced 22,000 shoes a day. It was vacant for over forty years. Paulus Development, utilizing the state and federal historic rehabilitation tax credit program, has transformed the iconic factory building to house over 150 market-rate apartments, plus commercial space.
Have all the Finger Lakes news from Finger Lakes News Radio delivered to your email every morning for FREE! Sign up by clicking here.
